10 bestRare Beanie Babiesof September 2025

TY Stubby Monkey Beanie Bellie Regular 6 Inches | Beanie Baby Soft Plush Toy | Collectible Cuddly Fabric Teddy

9.8

Erin the Irish Bear - Ty Beanie Baby

9.6

Early the Robin - TY Beanie Baby

Smartbuy

9.4

TY~BONSAI THE MONKEY BEANIE BABY

TY BONSAI THE MONKEY BEANIE BABY

9.2

TY 36316 Lemon Drop Chick Plush Yellow

9.0

OtherRelated productsUp to 25% off

THE TWIDDLERS Large Teddy Bear with I Love You, 50cm / 20" - Cute Plush Toy Gift for Her and Him, Birthday Gift for Girlfriend Boyfriend

PixieCrush Dog Stuffed Animals for Girls Ages 3-8 - Mommy Shiba Inu with 4 Puppies - Magical Dog Pillow Plushie - Enchanting Cuddly Companions for Imaginative Play

PixieCrush Unicorn Stuffed Animals for Girls Ages 3-8 - Mommy Cat Unicorn with 4 Baby Kittens - Magical Cat Pillow Plushies - Enchanting Plush Cat with Stuffed Kittens

Prextex Soft Plush Bunny Teddy with Zippered Pouch for Little Baby Bunnies - Adorable Toy Rabbit for Kids - Perfect Teddy Gift for Babies

TY Buckley Deer Beanie Babies

8.8

The Beginning Bear - Ty Beanie Baby

8.5

TY~MIDNIGHT THE PANTHER BEANIE BABY RARE

8.3

TY BEANIE - JERSEY THE COW - RARE

8.0

Swirly the Snail - Ty Beanie Baby

7.8